From noncovalent fragment to (non)covalent leads against PLPro

The most successful drug against COVID-19, nirmatrelvir, targets the main protease of SARS-CoV-2. As we discussed just last year, this protein has received considerable attention. But the genome for SARS-CoV-2 also encodes a second cysteine protease, papain-like protease, or PLPro. Despite this enzyme being essential for viral replication, the only previously disclosed chemical series targeting it dates from 2008 efforts against the original SARS. Two new papers in J. Med. Chem. from Stephen Fesik and colleagues at Vanderbilt University introduce new molecules, covalent and non-covalent.

 

One reason progress has been slow against PLPro is that it is inherently challenging. It recognizes the sequence LXGG, where X = Arg, Lys, or Asn. The two glycine residues thread a narrow channel to access the catalytic cysteine, while leucine and the “X” residue bind in solvent-exposed subsites. In 2024 the Fesik group published an open-access paper in ACS Med. Chem. Lett. describing the results of a protein-observed NMR fragment screen. Out of 13,824 fragments screened in pools of 12 at 0.8 mM each, 77 confirmed when tested individually, and 22 had affinities better than 1 mM.

 

An attractive feature of protein-observed NMR is that it tells you where the fragments bind, and in this case there were two main binding sites. One set of fragments bound in the S3 and S4 pockets, where the leucine and lysine residues of the substrate would normally fit, while another group of fragments bound some distance from the active site. Representatives from both groups were tested for inhibition of enzymatic activity. Only those in the first group were active, so these were prioritized.

 

In the first open-access J. Med. Chem. paper this year, the researchers started with compound 11, which fulfills rule-of-three fragment criteria, binds in the S4 pocket, and inhibits the enzyme with high-micromolar activity. Adding a couple methyl groups (compound 15) improved the potency by roughly 10-fold, and building towards the S3 pocket yielded compound 37, with low micromolar activity. Addition of a basic nitrogen, as in compound 46, improved the potency to submicromolar activity, and crystallography revealed that the basic nitrogen interacts with a glutamic acid side chain. This molecule was active in a cellular assay at submicromolar concentration.

 

An increasingly popular strategy for addressing difficult targets is through covalent inhibitors, and this is the subject of the second open-access J. Med. Chem. paper this year. The researchers synthesized and tested 25 analogs based on molecules such as compound 37 in which various warheads were appended by flexible linkers. Although some of these were active at low micromolar concentrations, only a few showed time-dependent activity as would be expected for an irreversible covalent inhibitor.

 

These few were optimized with the aid of molecular dynamics and structure-based design to molecules such as compound 45. Interestingly, despite being nearly 10-fold more potent than the best non-covalent molecule, it was less active in cells; the researchers attribute lower-than-hoped activity to the two hydrogen-bond donors in the diacetylhydrzaine linker. Unfortunately, these turned out to be essential for covalent binding; crystallography revealed that the compound forms four hydrogen bonds in the glycine channel. Indeed, this particular linker-warhead combination had been previously reported, and the inability to improve on it emphasizes the restrictive requirements for this particular protein.

 

This is a nice series of papers that shows how a single fragment can lead to multiple leads. The last paper is also a useful reminder that adding a warhead to a high-affinity binder is not always easy, nor does it necessarily lead to superior molecules. Indeed, neither the covalent nor the noncovalent leads have any reported in vitro ADME or pharmacokinetic data. It would be fun to screen PLPro against a library of covalent fragments to look for even more starting points.