Finding weak fragments for membrane proteins with WAC

Last week we wrote about NMR, one of the most popular fragment-finding methods. This week we turn to a less common technique: weak affinity chromatography, or WAC. As we’ve written previously, WAC involves immobilizing a protein of interest in a chromatography column and flowing a ligand-containing solution through the column. If the ligand interacts with the protein, its elution time will be delayed in proportion to its affinity. In a new (open-access) Molecules paper, Claire Demesmay and collaborators at Universite Claude Bernard Lyon and Ecole Supérieure de Biotechnologie de Strasbourg extend the technique to membrane proteins.

 

Membrane proteins are themselves tricky to study, since removing them from their membranes often denatures them. One trick is to use nanodiscs, which are tiny lipid bilayer islands surrounded by proteins that keep them soluble in water. These scaffolding proteins can also be biotinylated so that the nanondiscs can be attached to streptavidin, which itself can be linked to a surface or matrix. Each nanodisc holds one or at most a few membrane proteins.

 

When we first wrote about WAC in 2011 the technique used standard HPLC columns, which required non-negligible amounts of protein. Here, the technique has been miniaturized to use glass capillaries with volumes of less than 1 microliter, requiring only a few tens of picomoles of protein. The researchers fill the capillaries with a bio-compatible polymer, functionalize it with streptavidin, and then capture biotinylated nanodiscs containing the membrane protein of interest.

 

A long-recognized challenge with WAC is nonspecific binding of the fragments to the column or matrix. Here, the researchers chose a filling (or monolith) that is more hydrophilic (for aficionados, they picked poly(DHPMA-co-MBA)) and found it superior to the previous polymer both with regards to capacity and non-specific binding.

 

Another challenge with WAC is detecting low-affinity binders: because interactions with the protein are weak, the shift in retention time is harder to detect. One solution is to pack more protein in the column, and the researchers develop a clever way of doing this with a “multilayer grafting” approach in which successive injections of streptavidin and nanodiscs more effectively fill the capillary. The combination of a more hydrophilic filling and multilayer grafting increased the column capacity for nanodiscs by three-fold.

 

The researchers tested their approach on the adenosine-A2A receptor (AA_2AR), which has frequently been used as a model GPCR. Two previously reported weak ligands, both with affinities around 0.2 mM, could be detected, and competition with an orthosteric binder revealed that they were binding specifically.

 

This is a nice, how-to guide for performing WAC on membrane proteins, and the paper includes detailed equations for calculating affinities from differences in retention times. I look forward to seeing the technique used in de novo screens.